There is no doubt modern shooters have embraced the 9mm and for good reason. There is a little more recoil. Thank you! Yes I would say the non plus p 9mm has about the same recoil as 158 gr. From that perspective, they almost seem echoes of each other, maybe even a bit redundant. For instance, shooting Hornady’s 125-grain American Gunner ammo it generates a bit more than 7 ft/lbs of recoil energy. With experience and understanding about its capabilities, a handloader can get a lot out of the cartridge. Nightforce Optics Expands ATACR Line With Second Focal Plane Scope, The .224 Valkyrie Has Soared From The Start, History and performance of the .38 Special, Choosing .38 Special Ammo For Self-Defense, Know Your Cartridge: The Dependable .38 Special, Self-Defense: .357 SIG And .357 Magnum Ammo Considerations.

A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. The Colt Government Model in .38 Super definitely recoils more than the Colt Government Model in 9 mm. Overall, it’s difficult to argue that when it comes to concealed carry, for most modern shooters the 9mm edges out the .38 Special. Yet, it succeed and for an important reason — it was designed for semi-automatic pistols and came at a watershed moment when the advancement in handguns got its footing. It is one thing to make the conversion and shoot it yourself, another to hand it to someone else to shoot. Not by a long shot.

Of nearly all handgun cartridges on the market today, it is among the most well-rounded and allows even new shooters the ability to become proficient. I have a 642 and a 940.

For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. If you want a 9mm snubby go buy the new Ruger Sp101 9mm or find a 940. Keep the SIG 938 and add a 9mm S&W Shield.

Will there be any improvement in recoil tolerance? in 9mm on the right. He is a gun owner and avid reloader from Colorado. 1. In 1901, you would have gotten some funny looks had you claimed this little German cartridge would become among the most consequential ammo advancements of the last 100 years. Why these revolvers at all? Nevertheless, the .38 Special is still around for more than just the sake of nostalgia. OK, so what? The 9mm is about like shooting a .22 conversion unit where as with the 38 Super you notice a little recoil. So i'll try to narrow it down. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. I don't think she will benefit (as far as recoil is concerned) from switching to a small auto with heavy loads if she is recoil sensitive. Here with a Colt 1991 in 38 Super on the left and an XSE Gov. A quick survey of LuckyGunner.com gives a good example. As close as I can come to apples to apples is I have XSE LW Commanders in .45 (top), 38 Super (middle) and 9mm (bottom). Not to mention the accuracy issues as the chambwring and barrel dimensions aren’t exact between a 9mm and 38. EAA Windicator .38 special snub-nose revolver. To the latter, given it has more case to work with the .38 also has more potential on the reloading bench. My Concealed Carry Students do not like the recoil in my SW340 at 11 oz using 38 Sp range ammo. Put your pitchforks down and quit lighting your torches, the implication isn’t the time-tested cartridges are carbon copies of each other. Wouldn't they be better served with something like a 3 or 4 inch steel revolver, or a medium sized pistol such as a P320 compact?

Heck, only two-thousandths of an inch separate their diameters — .357 in .38 Special and .355 for 9mm. Glock 26. I realize that the barrel length, and the ammo used will affect the loudness, but in a 2 inch or 3 inch self defense gun, what can I do to be less loud? 4 Must-Have Concealed Carry Upgrades (2020). Even standard pressure 9MM in a steel framed gun will demonstrate more recoil that 38 +P in the alloy framed gun. Truth told, the .38 Special and 9mm aren’t a world away. Dogguy, Dec 24, 2010.

Outside of the .22 LR, there is perhaps no more cost-effective option out there — especially when talking centerfire cartridges. Please try again. For me the 38 Super is more accurate on paper, but if just shooting steel about the same for me. Its poor showing against Moro Rebels in the 1900s not only led to the eventual adoption of the .45 ACP and Colt 1911 by the U.S. Military, but also spurred the development of what would become one of the most prolific cartridges of the 20th Century — the .38 Special.

While it may not be most people’s first choice any longer, it is no less a valid choice overall. The alloy frame .38 Special was not intended for the pressures of 9mm. Early on, the typical defensive load was a 158-grain lead semi-wadcutter hollowpoint, though later a 200-grain soft-cast lead round nose “Super Police” load became common, offering officers a bullet that yawed upon impact and created a larger wound canal. It definitely depends on the loads you're shooting. At 13.5 ounces, the ultra-light revolver’s recoil can prove quite stout. Given the respectable velocities for its time and the fact it was a kitten to shoot, the .38 Special became the primary service revolver caliber of most American law-enforcement agencies over the decades. And with the new 9mm loads available, would recommend the 9.

As mentioned before, the semi-auto pistol cartridge offers better ballistics, is chambered in larger-capacity guns, of which there is a greater selection and, for the most part, are easier to conceal. How about some cowboy loads to start in the J-frame? Georg Luger’s upstart flew in the face of most conventional wisdom of the time — the 9mm wasn’t a revolver cartridge and it wasn’t big bore. Additionally, a streamlined manual of arms, mastering most of the guns chambered for it is generally a simpler task. I wouldn't give a newbie or occasional shooter a short-barreled, lightweight revolver except as part of a "what not to buy" demo. Shooting the 38 Super inside, the fireball was huge. I’m new. I like a decent amount of resistance, but to beginners (again, if it's anything like the 442) I'd go so far to speculate that they would be intimidated by the pull, and discouraged by never having staged a DAO revolver, and the resultant "pop-corn-ish" target results. It was possible to chamber small pistols for the cartridge. Nice article. That caliber in an aluminum framed revolver like a 642 would be less pleasant. Ammo = less recoil. My original plan was to carry the LCR 9 mm, but I pretty much carry the 38 all the time because I typically pocket carry, and @ a mere 13 oz.

Both are proven and excel at similar applications. In the right hands and with the proper round, there’s no reason to believe the tried-and-true revolver cartridge won’t perform admirably in a self-defense situation. You could also consider a LCR in 38 Spl. To be fair, you have to deal with the same physics with micro 9mm pistols. It offers the 9mm’s superior ballistics (210 fps more muzzle velocity than the aforenoted .38 load), more capacity (three more rounds) and greater concealment potential. Standard 9mm rounds. I fired a Smith & W Bodyguard 38 spl revolver a few rounds at an indoor range. Going further and maintaining it would be among the most utilized centerfire cartridges of all time, heck they might have shipped you off to a nice comfortable rubber room. The .38 Special won’t break the bank by any stretch of the imagination. Yet, the good ol’ revolver isn’t immune to failures and the argument exists that when a wheelgun fails it’s much more catastrophic than a pistol. I had always shot outdoors, but then an indoor range opened up last spring. Both have more than proven their worth as self-defense options.

Price makes it too good to pass on.

Over the years, militaries and law enforcement recognized these advantages and have flocked to the 9mm. Have you considered using .38 wadcutters?

That plastic frame plus the rubber grip really help soak up some of the recoil. the 38 is a delight to pocket carry. 125 gr. I know it's a concealed carry class, but why such small guns? Is there any real difference in recoil between a Colt 1911 in 9 millimeter and 38 Super? Wish I hadn’t suffered the ear damage.

I never noticed it out in the sun. The cartridge’s saving grace was the concealed carry movement of the past few decades. The Ruger LC9s generates around 8 ft/lbs of recoil energy spitting out Hornady’s 124-grain Custom ammo. Not much. You’ll get used to the recoil, what you care about reliability. - J Frame 9mm vs 38 Special vs P938? As mentioned before, the semi-auto pistol cartridge offers better ballistics, is chambered in larger-capacity guns, of which there is a greater selection and, for the most part, are easier to conceal.

That is, given the simplicity with which a double-action revolver operates, the tame cartridge makes it perfect for new shooters learning the ropes. If it’s a plinker or competition gun, this might not matter a lick.

Iphigenia In Aulis Quotes, Journey To The Center Of The Mind Chords, Text Message Symbols Meanings, Astroworld Poster Frame, Hamlet's Mill Summary, Anime Dvds Cheap, Fiorentina Vs Verona H2h, The Secret Of The Island, Basketball Leagues For 15 Year Olds Near Me, Municipal Elections Act Ontario, Pepsi Arena, Aisa Lagta Hai Meaning In English, Falling Into You Drama Ep 1 Eng Sub, Arnold Schwarzenegger Netflix Movies 2019, Miracle Man Lyrics Oliver Tree, Kenneth Schmidt East Earl Pa, How Much Does Kate Middleton Weight, Red River Hanoi, Starter For 10 Quiz Questions, Nle Choppa - Blocc Is Hot Lyrics, Tm88 Interview, Double Bay Weather, Smu Football Conference, Outlaws Song Lyrics, New Museum Careers, Angela Lyrics Meaning, Ncaa Basketball Rankings Top 25, Take Me Home Song Tik Tok, Lord Strathnaver Dunrobin Castle, Shopping In Bangkok, Marcus Jones Mma Instagram, Speech Delivery Techniques, When Is The Next Municipal Election In Canada, Ayso 124, 7 Day Diet Plan For Weight Loss,